With early voting underway in New York, Republican gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman is making a late push against Governor Kathy Hochul, hammering her on utility bills and public safety. But as the latest Quinnipiac poll shows Hochul holding a comfortable lead, political strategist Jack O’Donnell joins host Joanna Pasceri to assess whether Blakeman has any path left — and what cracks are showing in the national Republican coalition heading into the midterms. Plus, a celebratory moment: From the Lobby and O’Donnell & Associates’ Monday Morning Memo have both earned Silver Excalibur Awards from the PRSA Buffalo Niagara Chapter.

Joanna Pasceri

Countdown to Election Day. Early voting is underway. The attacks are intensifying and candidates are making their final push to win over voters. In the New York governor’s race, Republican candidate Bruce Blakeman is down but not out yet, and he’s hammering Governor Hochul on rising utility rates and public safety. Can he stage a comeback? Also across the country, concerns about the strength of the Republican coalition heading into the midterms with a president whose approval ratings are falling. Which strategies are working, and what should we be watching in these final days? Jack, so glad to have you join us from the lobby.

Jack O’Donnell

Joanna, great to be with you in this final stretch.

Joanna Pasceri

Early voting has started and now a new Quinnipiac poll shows Governor Hochul just days away from Election Day with a comfortable lead. Has Bruce Blakeman run out of time to change the outcome of this race?

Jack O’Donnell

Well, look, anything is possible in New York and in elections, and I do think the electorate remains incredibly volatile and angry. But yes, that poll is kind of remarkably consistent within a point or two of what we’ve been talking about for, I don’t know, five months now. Kathy Hochul has a steady low double digit lead here. Now, the hard part for everyone is getting people out to vote, right? Especially if the polls say you’re ahead. How do you keep people from being complacent? And if the polls say you’re down, how do you get people to kind of do something anyway?

And that’s one of the interesting findings in that Quinnipiac does show that the Blakeman voters, or a lot of them, are more enthusiastic about voting and voting for him than some of Kathy Hochul’s voters. So there’s still a little ways to go, but I’d much rather be Kathy Hochul right now.

Joanna Pasceri

Blakeman is hitting the campaign trail hard, trying to make up ground by hammering Governor Hochul on the cost of living. He met with small business owners facing soaring utility bills and blamed Hochul. The governor is pointing the finger at President Trump and his war in Iran for the increase in energy costs. Who has the stronger argument?

Jack O’Donnell

They’re both right. It’s everybody’s fault. I do think the governor has been really smart about this. Hochul has been talking about affordability for the last four years, right back to rebate checks and groceries. Now, you could say she hasn’t done enough or what she’s done hasn’t had a big enough impact. But I think voters believe, and we see in a lot of these polls, that she cares about those concerns. And I do think at the end of the day, a lot of voters see the war in Iran as a real driving factor on energy costs. And they know that’s not the decision, not the unilateral decision of the Governor of New York the way it was of the President of the United States.

So I do think people are fed up. Republicans are feeling it, and we’re seeing a lot of these national polls kind of move away from Republicans. But I think in large part that’s because Republicans are in power. We always see some correction in president’s midterms. But I also think more broadly it’s just an anti-incumbent feeling. People aren’t happy with the status quo and everybody feels that. But in general, Kathy Hochul’s doing a good job of swimming against that tide.

Joanna Pasceri

Public safety is another major part of Blakeman’s closing argument. He recently took his campaign onto the New York City subway, calling for more police, more conductors, better lighting. Is this effective?

Jack O’Donnell

I think that public safety is a real concern, but it tends to be a concern more likely or higher ranked by Republican voters who should already be with him. And it’s just too little, too late. He should have been riding the subway once a week for the last six months. And in a world where even Republican voters are saying one of their biggest concerns is corruption in government, that doesn’t answer that and that doesn’t fix the affordability and that doesn’t fix the idea of jobs and economic development and education and future for their kids. So, is it effective? Yes, but with a small group of the electorate, and I don’t think that’s enough to turn the tide.

Joanna Pasceri

Is there anything that would turn the tide in the last week for Blakeman? If you were running his campaign, you’ve worked on campaigns at the highest levels — what kind of advice would you have? Or what does he need?

Jack O’Donnell

Well, that’s just a tough one. I am a big believer that campaigns are won sometimes two years in advance. The get out the vote, the field operation, everything you do leading up to Election Day matters. But how you frame the election and how you frame awareness of who you are is really important. And that’s where I think Bruce Blakeman and his campaign have missed. Coming in hot now is good, but a lot of opinions are formed. I think the thing most people know about Bruce Blakeman is his association with Donald Trump. And this year that is not helpful. Hochul also has the resources to kind of see this thing through. And she and her campaign are a big part of the reason people know that about Blakeman.

So Blakeman’s opportunity to frame himself as a competent executive, as a forward-looking executive, all of those things — having a vision for restoring affordability or restoring economic competitiveness in New York State — that ship has sailed on him. And so he’s reduced to these subway stunts, which will get some coverage, but if not part of a deeper, longer strategy to bring in different groups of voters in other parts of the state, it’s too little, too late. He needs some sort of defining event to either change people’s perception of Kathy Hochul or of him. And I don’t think he’s going to get that in the next few days.

Joanna Pasceri

Let’s turn to races across the country. Political observers are seeing roughly a dozen House races moving in Democrats’ direction, raising big questions about the Republican coalition that helped put Trump in the White House a couple of years ago. Despite his declining approval numbers, the president is hitting the campaign trail in deep red states. Is this a good idea, having him energize the base?

Jack O’Donnell

Well, I think you’re seeing the culmination of the Republican congressional relationship with Donald Trump, which is they let him do whatever he wants to do. And so him being out in these states — look, he’s staying in places where he has been popular in the past. And so at least there is some cushion there of appreciation or support for Donald Trump. So that may help motivate some of those disinclined Republican voters. But I think this coalition is cracked. You’re seeing, especially in places like Texas, Hispanic voters who were a huge part of the winning Republican and Trump coalition two years ago, have abandoned the party in large aspects.

So I don’t think he can put it together. It’s more, can you stop the bleeding? The numbers we’re seeing out there in polls — and of course, I don’t want to get lost in the polls, they are snapshots in time and they can change, just ask Hillary Clinton about polling — but at the same time, the New York Times poll yesterday had Democrats up plus 11 on the generic congressional ballot. Four months ago, it was, wow, if Democrats could get to six there, they would win the House. So anything could happen. All of these models show there could be a Democratic wave, but at the same time, it could be more of a trickle. We saw that four years ago under Biden. Republicans were gonna have a huge, huge night, and it ended up being less than. I’m still a little more inclined that way. Not all of this shows that I think Democrats win. I don’t know that it’s a wave, but, gosh, that’s why we run the elections.

Joanna Pasceri

Before we let you go, let’s take a moment to pat ourselves on the back here and proudly announce that this podcast, From the Lobby with Jack O’Donnell, recently won a Silver Excalibur Award from the Public Relations Society of America Buffalo Niagara Chapter for excellence in communications. And our Monday Morning Memo was also honored, receiving its third Silver Excalibur award. So how does it feel, Jack?

Jack O’Donnell

It feels pretty cool, doesn’t it, Joanna? Look, you make a lot of these things happen, and you are so skilled in this area. You’re always making me look good. But our whole team puts a lot of time and effort into this. I just come with this approach that too many people in this space have always tried to say, well, I do things behind closed doors, you can’t know what we do or what’s happening. And we use the memo, we use this podcast to try to throw that door open and tell people what’s happening. We may not always be right, but we’re always right to start the discussion and to be a part of it and encourage it. So it feels great. Want to thank the Society for recognizing us, but especially want to thank you. Great work. Really proud of us.

Joanna Pasceri

Thank you. It’s been my pleasure. But I think what really stands out is your ability early on to jump on these things before anyone else in the government relations realm. The newsletter — really, before many people were doing that. And in the podcast arena in your field, you just don’t see it. So I think you’re breaking some good ground in the work that you’re doing. Great being with you from the lobby, Jack.

Jack O’Donnell

Thanks so much, Joanna.

Subscribe to From the Lobby and sign up for Jack’s Monday Morning Memo — a weekly, no-paywall look at the top political and policy stories — at odonnellsolutions.com.