The votes are counted, and the political landscape has shifted dramatically. On this episode of From the Lobby, host Joanna Pasceri sits down with Jack O’Donnell, managing partner of O’Donnell & Associates, to dissect a historic Democratic sweep: Governor Kathy Hochul’s 20-point blowout over Bruce Blakeman, record-breaking supermajorities in both chambers of the New York State Legislature, and Democratic gains across the country that flipped control of Congress. O’Donnell argues the results were as much a referendum on Donald Trump as a vote for Democrats — and warns that governing the coalition, from the Blue Dogs to the progressive left, will be the real test. Here’s the conversation.

Joanna Pasceri

Election day is in the books and the message voters sent could not be more clear. From a decisive victory in New York to Democratic gains across the country, a blue wave swept through races at every level of government. Republicans are left picking up the pieces, and Washington is about to look very different. Hi, everybody, and welcome to From the Lobby with Jack O’Donnell. We’re breaking down the winners, the losers and the political fallout after the historic midterm elections. Joining me is Jack O’Donnell, managing partner of O’Donnell & Associates, one of New York’s top lobbying firms. He’s a political strategist and longtime observer of the political landscape. Jack, great to have you back from the lobby.

Jack O’Donnell

Joanna, what a week, huh?

Joanna Pasceri

Quite a night on election night. So let’s get right into it. Let’s start with Governor Hochul’s blowout victory. She won by 20 points over Republican Bruce Blakeman. That’s even better than her strongest poll going into election day. So was this a surprise to you?

Jack O’Donnell

Not a surprise that she won, but her margin was both surprising and impressive. Look, a 20 point victory in any state is amazing. A 20 point victory against a credible opponent who had resources, who represents one of the biggest counties in the state — it’s really impressive. Well done, Governor Hochul.

Joanna Pasceri

Well, not just Governor Hochul winning big. Democrats in the New York State legislature added an expected 14 seats, giving them supermajorities in both houses and the largest majorities in the legislature’s history. So what’s behind this historic result and what impact do you think it will have on governing?

Jack O’Donnell

Look, it was a Democratic year across the country, right? And I know we’ll talk about that, but New York was no exception. And I think some of this is down to candidates and campaigns. Hochul ran a really good campaign. Carl Heastie and the Assembly Campaign Committee, especially with recruitment and how they deployed their resources. The Senate Democrats under the leadership of Shelley Mayer, who just took over as head of the DSCC and really threw herself into that role. Both things matter. It really helps to have that wind at your sails, but at the same time, you’ve got to be in a position to take advantage of it. And again, this starts with candidate recruitment. The Democrats in New York did a really good job on that and raised a lot of money and put it to work. So well done to all of them, and I think they deserve some credit for it. But it gets multiplied in a year like this, so good for them.

The harder question is, what does this mean for governing. We have, as you mentioned, never seen majorities like this. And the bigger the majority, the more unwieldy it can get. We’ve seen some of that in the State Assembly, but I don’t know that that much changes other than you’re going to have some even louder voices for some core or center-left Democratic priorities and push and pull to try to move both conferences and to try to move the governor to the left. That’s really one of the dynamics we’ll be watching going forward. Both of these chambers and their huge Democratic majorities are going to say, look at us, look at how strong we are. You’ve got to do what we want to do. And Governor Hochul’s going to say, yeah, but look at me. You came in on my coattails. So the unstoppable force and the immovable object will meet come budget time, and we’ll be watching.

Joanna Pasceri

Democrats, as you said, made major gains across the country, taking control of Congress, winning at virtually every level of government. The pundits predicted a blue wave, but the size of the victory was striking. Was this a vote for Democrats or more of a vote against Republicans?

Jack O’Donnell

Well, I think it starts with a vote against Donald Trump. I said this on election night. Governor Hochul said the same thing. Donald Trump asked America to vote as if he was on the ballot, and they did. I think Americans are unhappy with the direction of the country. They’re unhappy with the war in Iran, they’re unhappy with tariffs. They’re unhappy with the cost of gas and the cost of living in America right now. And they’re even more unhappy that the leaders don’t seem to care. The fact that Trump’s closing argument here was about the reflecting pool in Washington and not about caring about you or I came really back to hurt Republicans across the ballot.

And you’ve got to give Democrats some credit for that — for positioning themselves, really focusing on the economy. You can go back to the government shutdown a few months ago and the number of people who were critical of Hakeem Jeffries and the number of people in New York and across the country who were critical of Chuck Schumer and how they handled that. But they literally changed the direction of this campaign and brought it back to the economy and affordability and people’s pocketbooks. That paid off. And again, I’ve said this about the legislature. It is twice or three times as true about the congressional committees in Washington. Candidate recruitment really mattered here, and especially in the Senate. You saw Chuck Schumer go back to people who had won statewide in Ohio, in Alaska, in North Carolina. That mattered. And those folks won handily. And then they’re able to expand the map, use their resources to play in other places. We heard an awful lot from Democrats on the left who thought Schumer’s choice, the DSCC choice in Maine, was uninspiring, in Governor Mills and everything that went on there. But boy, their decision making, their focus, their choices look pretty good today.

Joanna Pasceri

Well, Democrats have the momentum, but now comes the hard part. Voters have handed them a mandate and expectations I’m sure are high. What should be at the top of their agenda? How much can they truly accomplish?

Jack O’Donnell

That remains to be seen. I do think that the tough part is the governing. I was reminded of Robert Redford and The Candidate, right? He wins and then he says, oh my gosh, now what? And we’re kind of at that point for Democrats in Washington. The hard part for them is what kind of partner shows up in the White House. Is that the President Trump that we saw on the campaign trail two years ago who really spoke to voters and really was able to harness their concerns and focus on economics? Or is it the Donald Trump who’s pursuing regime change in South America, Cuba and the Middle East? I don’t know, and I don’t know that they know.

So I think Democrats have to start with an economic argument and an economic package that they’re going to pass and really put some of those choices front and center for the President and for the American people. If they do that, that’ll go a long way. There will be a lot of energy from the left about impeachment, about investigations, and certainly there has to be a reckoning about some of the corruption and maybe some of these Cabinet secretaries and what they’re doing. But if Democrats get distracted by those things and are only going to talk about what’s wrong, this is going to be a short-lived majority.

Joanna Pasceri

While Republican losses have prompted finger pointing, questions about leadership, messaging and strategy — what does the GOP do now?

Jack O’Donnell

That’s also going to play out here. And just as Democrats need to keep their coalition together, Republicans need to start putting a new coalition together. The folks who turned out for Republicans on Tuesday are not a national coalition. They lost Hispanics, they lost a lot of young men who had come out for them a couple years ago. They further lost educated women across the country. And that gets hard when your party is decimated. We saw that with Democrats in 1994. How do you react? Because a lot of the Republicans who are left in office who’ve been reelected are going to be further to the right and are going to be concerned more about their right flanks and about primaries than about moving to the center.

I really want to emphasize one of these points. There’s been so much talk about the Democratic left and the DSA and the progressives, and they’re an important part of this coalition. But the folks who won on Tuesday, a lot of them are center-left, moderate Democrats. You see that in the Blue Dog coalition in Washington — the Democratic Blue Dogs are doubling. The progressives are not. They’re going up, but it’s these folks who win those purple seats that are the ones who are going to have the most say in the future of this party. And if Republicans want to push back, they’ve got to be able to recapture some of that ground. Can they do that while Trump is in the White House? Can they separate themselves from this administration and its unpopular decisions? That’s going to be really hard to do.

Joanna Pasceri

And finally, Jack, just like that, the political world is already looking ahead to 2028, when the White House is up for grabs. How much does this election change the presidential landscape?

Jack O’Donnell

Well, I do think everyone is going to be going to their scorecards. How much did this person who wants to be president campaign for candidates who won, who lost? Who’s got ideas that match the national electorate and the mood here? So I do think a lot of Democrats are going to look for folks who did well and see how that matches up. A lot of those eyes right now are on places like Georgia, but we’ll see how that plays out. But absolutely, we are in day three or four of the 2028 presidential campaign.

Joanna Pasceri

Jack, thanks for your insight.

Jack O’Donnell

Great to be with you, Joanna.

Joanna Pasceri

One thing is certain. Election day may be over, but the political consequences are just getting started. Subscribe to this podcast so you don’t miss a thing. And for a deeper look at the election results and the political aftershocks still to come, don’t miss Jack’s Monday Morning Memo. Sign up to have it sent to your inbox each week at odonnellsolutions.com. I’m Joanna Pasceri. Thanks for listening, everyone. We’ll see you next time on From the Lobby with Jack O’Donnell.