From a fiery gubernatorial debate to a billionaire’s nine-figure midterm investment to the slow fade of a New York City institution, this week’s From the Lobby covers a political landscape in flux. Host Joanna Pasceri sits down with Jack O’Donnell — Albany insider, campaign strategist, and Managing Partner of O’Donnell & Associates — to assess who gained ground in the Kathy Hochul-Bruce Blakeman showdown, whether Elon Musk’s $276 million in Republican donations can offset Democratic momentum heading into the midterms, and what Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s deal to phase out horse carriages means for a decades-long city debate.
Joanna Pasceri
Kathy Hochul and Bruce Blakeman just wrapped up their first and only debate. There were plenty of clashes. When you look at the matchup as a whole, who performed the best?
Jack O’Donnell
Well, what a good question. I mean, always, I think if you’re the incumbent, if you’re ahead, you know, you’re kind of playing to protect the lead. And Governor Kathy Hochul protected her lead. She has always been really good at staying on message, and she continued to do that. We heard Blakeman, Trump, we heard Trump, Blakeman, we heard Blakeman, Blakeman, Trump, Trump, et cetera, et cetera. So I think she hit her marks. Blakeman had the harder job. He’s not as well known. He’s behind. I thought he landed one or two punches, especially on Cornell. And about the, what do you have to lose? But he didn’t force a mistake. I don’t think he was able to change the trajectory of this race. And so even if he did a little better on points the other night, he doesn’t get the win, if that makes any sense.
Joanna Pasceri
One report found Hochul tied Blakeman to President Trump more than 40 times during the debate. That’s a lot of Trump talk. Was this a smart strategy or did she overplay her hand here?
Jack O’Donnell
Well, I think it’s a strategy she’s decided on. We’ve talked here in our Monday morning memo about how I would like to see more from her and her campaign about not just what she’s done as governor, but a little bit more about what she intends to do, what the future looks like. But the campaign really doubled down on this Trump theme. And look, if the polls are any indication, it’s working. And so while I personally would like to see more and would push the campaign to offer a little more of that vision, in terms of her strategy, she’s delivering on that.
Joanna Pasceri
Blakeman came out swinging, calling Hochul the worst governor in America and blaming her for the state’s problems. Do those hard-hitting attacks resonate with voters?
Jack O’Donnell
Well, I think it resonates a lot with people who already don’t like Kathy Hochul. Again, I think folks really spoke to their audiences here. At one point I talked about this as a commercial. I mean, it was almost like we saw alternating commercials between Hochul’s about and Blakeman’s about Hochul and sort of back and forth. I think he needs to do more to break through and he hasn’t done that. And he’s really running out of time if he hasn’t already.
Joanna Pasceri
So as you said, he talked to his supporters. Do you think he gained any votes after that debate?
Jack O’Donnell
I don’t. I mean, I don’t imagine there were a lot of undecided voters watching either. So the way to reach those folks is to find that viral moment, either goading, or arguing, debating Kathy Hochul into a corner, or offering up some inspiration. And neither of those things happened, which is why you and I are talking about this. This is in our world, but it hasn’t moved into another world — the world of independent voters, undecided voters, people trying to figure out what to do next. And they can be hard to reach. These are people who are very busy with jobs, with children, caring for parents. And that’s why they haven’t made up their mind. And I don’t think anyone reached them.
Joanna Pasceri
Let’s turn now to Washington. Democrats are gaining ground in several congressional races and it’s looking like they’ll take over Congress in the new year. But Republicans have major financial advantages — Elon Musk alone donating $276 million to Republican groups. Can that campaign cash change the outcome in races where Democrats have the momentum?
Jack O’Donnell
Well, I think Democrats definitely have the momentum. I do think there’s a shift underway here. We’re seeing it in those polls and a lot of it comes from the president on down, and that the president has not delivered on his campaign promises. And I think voters feel like he’s distracted talking about the Kennedy Center, the war in Iran, in terms of real life, my grocery bill, the things that families are dealing with as they’re trying to put food on the table. Republicans have not had a good message there. Now, on the other hand, Democrats’ best message, most effective message has been we’re not them. And so a lot of these votes seem to be people who are looking to vote against Republicans. Now, what does that mean in practical terms? I still think there’s a long way to go with a really volatile, really angry electorate. We are seeing people angry with the White House and Congress and wanting to go back. But we’re also hearing there are similar sentiments in places like New York where people are unhappy with Albany, in California, people unhappy with Sacramento, and on and on and on. So there’s still a lot of race left to be run and Republicans who are able to find and hone that message are still going to do well. So right now I think Democrats are going to win, but it matters a lot how much they win by and how many seats.
Joanna Pasceri
In New York City, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and the city council speaker have agreed to phase out the horse carriage industry. It’s the latest chapter in this debate that’s been going on for decades. What do you think? Is this the right move for the city?
Jack O’Donnell
Well, you know, I like the horse carriages and have a lot of sympathy for the union members who have made those investments and who are doing that work. It has felt for a while now like they’ve been living on borrowed time. I expect we’ll see a court challenge to some of this, but, you know, always sad to see things from the last era sort of disappear. But progress is always coming.
Joanna Pasceri
Jack, another great conversation. Thanks for joining us from the Lobby.
Jack O’Donnell
Good to talk to you. Thanks, Joanna.
Never miss an episode. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. For more insight from Jack, sign up for his Monday Morning Memo at odonnellsolutions.com.
